Tyler Babbie’s 3rd Review: Eric Pankey’s Reliquaries
Eric Pankey’s book Reliquaries did not thrill me much. It is a very long book of lyric poetry, fifty poems long. Only a few of the poems reached me. Those that did were quite good, and those that didn’t weren’t bad. Just not the flavor I favor.
One thing that seems common in contemporary poetry is a tendency to reference other works of art and music. This sort of ekphrasis is tricky to pull off gracefully. Some of Pankey’s poems seem like tributes to his playlist, such as “Let Me Rest on that Peaceful Mountian.” The second stanza of the poem is a list of Bob Dylan’s favorite tunes, then Pankey’s. I don’t quite know how to take that, but it doesn’t read interestingly despite the strange line breaks. The poem ends in a sort of abstract nowhere, “How often the out-there seems a diorama, a lesson in an enclosure, an example of the real.” Sure, I understand that he is looking out the window of a car, but I also don’t quite get the transition from Dylan’s favorites to this driving home. The poem does invoke senility and the difficulty of threading thoughts together, but I am nearly certain that the poem’s disunity is not intended to reflect an aging mind.
I will say that I am extremely picky in my poetry, and I usually tend to love poems that sound amazing whether what they mean is interesting or not. Pankey’s soundwork is less than ornate, which means I cannot be more than lukewarm to his work.
But enough of that, there are some good poems here. “Salvaged Nails” has the sound and the depth that I appreciate. The poem is about summer jobs held in his youth, and interesting memory-poem and well written, too. My favorite line in the book is this one: “The hay chaff and dust glint and flicker in the loft-light as I doze and laze in the barn’s slatted shade.” That line sounds great. The assonances and alternation of heavy and light stress patterns make it stand out to me as a wonderful line. Looking past the sound, the poem contains multiple statements about humanity and life that are subsumed into the narrative, as in Faulkner or other great writers. Pankey examines the human striving to create and the fragility of our mortal bodies. Family, work, sleep, light; there are details enough for me to think about and the sound makes me want more poetry like this.
One thing that puzzled me throughout the book was its line breaks, which tend to extend past the physical page. Long lines take on the look of continuity, while the hanging indents make it clear that there is actually no such thing. I wonder what the book would look like as a rectangle, turned on its side. The lines would be very long and perhaps ragged. It seems dishonest to bend a poem to fit a page, but that is probably a publishing issue more than an artistic one.
Overall, I was not too excited by this book. Fifty poems are a lot to ask of anyone, and I think that Eric Pankey may have put a few too many in Reliquaries. As wonderful as a shapely volume may be, it is perhaps more important to distill a few high-quality poems than make the even fifty. There are good poems and very good poems in this book- but it is work to find them.
Review 3
Eric Pankey’s Reliquaries
Eric Pankey’s book Reliquaries did not thrill me much. It is a very long book of lyric poetry, fifty poems long. Only a few of the poems reached me. Those that did were quite good, and those that didn’t weren’t bad. Just not the flavor I favor.
One thing that seems common in contemporary poetry is a tendency to reference other works of art and music. This sort of ekphrasis is tricky to pull off gracefully. Some of Pankey’s poems seem like tributes to his playlist, such as “Let Me Rest on that Peaceful Mountian.” The second stanza of the poem is a list of Bob Dylan’s favorite tunes, then Pankey’s. I don’t quite know how to take that, but it doesn’t read interestingly despite the strange line breaks. The poem ends in a sort of abstract nowhere, “How often the out-there seems a diorama, a lesson in an enclosure, an example of the real.” Sure, I understand that he is looking out the window of a car, but I also don’t quite get the transition from Dylan’s favorites to this driving home. The poem does invoke senility and the difficulty of threading thoughts together, but I am nearly certain that the poem’s disunity is not intended to reflect an aging mind.
I will say that I am extremely picky in my poetry, and I usually tend to love poems that sound amazing whether what they mean is interesting or not. Pankey’s soundwork is less than ornate, which means I cannot be more than lukewarm to his work.
But enough of that, there are some good poems here. “Salvaged Nails” has the sound and the depth that I appreciate. The poem is about summer jobs held in his youth, and interesting memory-poem and well written, too. My favorite line in the book is this one: “The hay chaff and dust glint and flicker in the loft-light as I doze and laze in the barn’s slatted shade.” That line sounds great. The assonances and alternation of heavy and light stress patterns make it stand out to me as a wonderful line. Looking past the sound, the poem contains multiple statements about humanity and life that are subsumed into the narrative, as in Faulkner or other great writers. Pankey examines the human striving to create and the fragility of our mortal bodies. Family, work, sleep, light; there are details enough for me to think about and the sound makes me want more poetry like this.
One thing that puzzled me throughout the book was its line breaks, which tend to extend past the physical page. Long lines take on the look of continuity, while the hanging indents make it clear that there is actually no such thing. I wonder what the book would look like as a rectangle, turned on its side. The lines would be very long and perhaps ragged. It seems dishonest to bend a poem to fit a page, but that is probably a publishing issue more than an artistic one.
Overall, I was not too excited by this book. Fifty poems are a lot to ask of anyone, and I think that Eric Pankey may have put a few too many in Reliquaries. As wonderful as a shapely volume may be, it is perhaps more important to distill a few high-quality poems than make the even fifty. There are good poems and very good poems in this book- but it is work to find them.
Recent Comments